91 points James Suckling: "Fine bubbles with a steely, sliced pear and apple character. Medium-to full-bodied, layered and fruity. Some minerally undertones. Off-dry, soft and lush. 50% chardonnay and 50% pinot noir. Drink now." 91 points Wine Enthusiast: "A well-rounded, supple texture surrounds attractive toast and nut flavors in this suave and mouthfilling wine. Notes of biscuit, peach and toasted bread give it a nice sense of maturity and complexity. (JG)" (12/2020) 90 points Wine Spectator: "Vibrant and steely, with lemon, apple, creamy and toast...

90 points Connoisseurs Guide: "Just as it did in last year’s survey of sparkling wines, Scharffenberger’s Brut Rosé once again impresses with its fine combination of deep, slightly juicy, very well-stated fruit and integral autolysis. It is a deftly balanced wine with a steady, very long-lasting stream of tiny bubbles, and, although we continue to be happily surprised at the number of affordable sparklers that merit 'Good Value' recommendation, this wine’s buoyancy, intricate layering and careful crafting earns it an especially enthusiastic nod as nothin...