Old Pulteney 17 year old Single Malt Whisky 750ml (Elsewhere $90)

While the Old Pulteney 21 recently won the title of "Best Whisky in the World," we here at K&L couldn't help but be reminded of that old John Lennon quip about Ringo ("Best drummer in the world? He's not even the best drummer in the Beatles!"). The 17 year old is far better in our opinion, offering more nuance than its older brother. If you're a true Scotch fan, then you'll appreciate the brilliance of the Old Pulteney 17 Year because it's a dying breed these days. A creamy mouthfeel with flavors of vanilla, dried apricots, vanilla, and sweet cereal grains is what enticed to me go back for a second sip. This is vintage Highland whisky and I love everything about it. The stonefruit still lingers on the tongue more than five minutes after tasting it and the caramel becomes more stated. I can't believe I'm writing this, but in this case it's appropriate: they don't make 'em like Pulteney anymore. I wish they did. Now that it's riding the coattails of its older brother into a higher price bracket, this might be the last time we see it under $100. (David Driscoll, K&L Spirits Buyer)