2005 San Giusto a Rentennano "Percarlo"
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
The 2005 Percarlo is understandably a bit tight today. It has great energy and drive from start to finish. The aromas and flavors are quite nuanced and sculpted. Freshly cut flowers, licorice and spices are some of the many notes that come alive in the glass. Ultimately the 2005 stands apart for its gorgeous delineation and finesse. I will not be surprised if the 2005 ends up blossoming even more in bottle. Anticipated maturity: 2015-2025. (AG)
The 2005 Percarlo is another highlight of the vintage. Here it is the wine's freshness that really stands out. The 2005 isn't a big Percarlo, but has lovely understated energy and detail, not to mention considerable personality. Sweet dark cherries, smoke, game, tobacco and licorice meld into the expressive finish. Firm tannins shape the finish. The 2005 will never be an especially refined or huge Percarlo and yet there is something about the wine's balance and overall sense of proportion that just works. (AG)
Notes on San Giusto a Rentennano from the Wine Advocate, issue #201, regarding a Percarlo vertical; "This complete vertical of Percarlo left me speechless. Brothers Luca and Francesco Martini di Cigala showed me every vintage of Percarlo, back to the inaugural 1983, a wine that has now run its full course. I was deeply struck by the consistency of the wines from year to year, and even more importantly, by the great showing of a number of wines from long forgotten vintages, proving yet again the importance of choosing producer over vintage. Percarlo started off as a selection of the estate’s best vineyards. In 2001 the Cigalas sharpened their approach by focusing on what is now literally a bunch by bunch selection across all of the fruit that comes into the winery, an approach they favor because of the huge inconsistency Sangiovese can often show from vine to vine, and even within the same cluster. I also tasted a few vintages of the Chianti Classico Le Baroncole, the top Sangiovese bottling made in vintages not deemed suitable for Percarlo. Readers who want to learn more about San Giusto and Percarlo may want to take a look at my recent video interview with proprietor Luca Martini di Cigala."